The Date is 2006

The WHI Dietary Study was closed in 1998, because of poor outcomes.

Researchers at the time were sure they had the best possible data records.

They were confused; "We know what a healthy diet is."

They tried to re-examine their work for almost eight years, looking for a more favourable outcome.

Eventually they had to admit that their expectations were wrong.

We clearly "don't know what a healthy diet is."

But we do now know what a health diet is NOT.

The S.A.D is Not Healthy

Yet that remains the basis of Healthy Diet Guidelines around the English speaking world. We choose NOT to follow the science.

Women's Health Initiative Success

The Authorities Didn't Like the Result

There are no meaningful health advantages, in LFHC diet for older women.

The Standard American Diet fails the Health Test.

Those with existing heart disease did worse.

Those with existing diabetes did worse.

There was weight loss: average weight loss only 1lb (less than half a kg.) over 8 yrs.

Because of the good control, they know the women reduced total calories eaten, by 350kcal a day.

On the basis of 9000kcal a kg, they should have lost 14kg a year. It didn't happen. Calories in v calories out is a nonsense. Weight essentially remained stable. Homeostasis wins.

Sadly, no Nobel Prize of the researchers.

The National Institute of Health, the main source of funding, refuses to accept the WHI result

But the Result, makes clear sense of the old Framingham Study.
All those "black swans" now fit into a sensible framework.