Open Future Health

The Omnivores Mixed Diet Paradigm

In the USA there was great concern about the growing number of heart disease deaths. President Eisenhower died of a heart attack. Several prominent politicians had weight problems and heart attack scares.

Senator George McGovern, long time Senator, but a failed presidential candidate, wanted to leave his mark on America. He established a committee to study and recommend a "Diet Related to Killer Diseases" for Americans. They largely adopted a diet recommended by Mark Hegsted, professor of nutrition at Harvard. The diet was altered to recognise some political realities, after significant lobbying from food producers and industry.

The diet that became the first generally accepted paradigm for human nutrition, was only a slight variation on what many people ate anyway. The diet gives a nod to eating less red meat. The diet does not tell us to eliminate any food from our diet. The diet is intended to support the American farmer. The diet is friendly towards commercial interests, because first of all, it's a political compromise.

Standard American Diet for Health

Glucose Based Metabolism (Normal for most of us.)

Your Brain is Glucose Dependent

Even when your energy supply is glucose heavy, about half of your energy still comes from free fatty acids. But your brain probably runs on glucose 100% of the time.

This is why Diabetes Associations, even though they know how excess carbohydrate raise blood sugar, and causes metabolic problems for their members, still recommend that every meal contains about 60gm of carbohydrate. If your sugars get too low, you will probably pass out, they believe.

Glucose can readily be transformed into acetyl-Coenzyme A, but the reverse is not true. Once glucose becomes acetyl-CoA, it can't reverse itself.

Remember the blood MUST retrain a constant level of glucose. Excess glucose must be eliminated quickly. Insulin will remain in control until that's accomplished. That's a very important fact, because the fat around your waist can only come from glucose. The building of triglycerides, a process called lipogenesis (making fat), cannot occur inside the mitochondria (The fatty acids from dietary fats go there).

Most of the cells in your body will also easily accept free fatty acids as fuel, if insulin is low and not preventing that from happening. However, because free fatty acids are too big to cross the blood brain barrier, free fatty acids cannot fuel the brain.

Fat burning turns on overnight.

If you are healthy, in the morning after a long overnight fast, you may be in a mild state of ketosis. Take a 10k run before eating and you will almost certainly produce ketosis. Your body will mostly be using fats, unless you try to sprint. There is glycogen in your cells, but the body tries to conserve that. You have enough fuel to run for about three hours before the supply of glycogen becomes compromised.

Most of us, get up and eat breakfast. We tend to have muesli and fruit with low-fat yoghurt, and green-top milk. Two slices of toast, with margarine and honey or jam, plus a cup of black coffee with one sugar. Eating this "healthy" breakfast turns fat burning "off", and turns insulin "on."

Or we skip breakfast.

Continuous Carbohydrate Recharging

Morning tea is a challenge. A muffin and coffee, would be normal.

Lunch for most of us involves sandwiches or some other bread, bun, pasta or rice based food. We frequently finish with a muffin or cookie as we have tea or coffee. Lunch will often increase your blood sugars to more than ten times normal.

So the day continues, eating more carbohydrates every 2.5 hours, boosting our blood sugars AGAIN, and turning on insulin to clear up the damage we've done.

This behaviour continues after the evening meal, finishing with supper about 10pm.

The point is; that the way we eat, and the food we choose to eat, keeps insulin "on" all day. Over many years your body reacts to that, by changing your homeostasis set point. You adapt to all the carbohydrate you are eating, first of all by using insulin to help you cope with the carbohydrate overload. But eventually the continuous excess of insulin in your system begins to cause a problem, by creating carbohydrate resistance. (That's why Open Future Health recommends a long daily fast, 10-12 hours every day. Give insulin a chance to clear from your system completely.)

Young people cope quite well with this diet, but that changes as they age, and they begin to get fat. They develop metabolic syndrome, beginning in mid-life. This leads to a series of late life health problems that reduce one's enjoyment of life, and may mean 10 or more years of disability. Diabetes, heart problems, strokes, arthritis, gout and dementia are all connected to metabolic syndrome.

Authorities tell us that the solution is for middle aged people to exercise more. That comes back to the belief that the key is energy in v energy out. But other sources tell us that while exercise has many health benefits, but it's rather ineffective in helping us reduce our weight.

So we know what happens. The question is, can there be a practical alternative?

There certainly is. You might not need to change paradigms either, that depends on how much damage you've already done to your body. Forget about diets. Don't count calories. If you weigh too much DON'T exercise, either, you'll only damage yourself. Get an education, read this web site and the blog. Buy yourself some sensible books. (Harder that it looks.) Try Hugh Butler's "Take Out Diet." Think about how you CONTROL the hormone insulin, by your eating pattern. Eventually that's the secret people don't know. Read the sidebar to the right.

The Standard Mixed Diet

Key belief system

Glucose is essential for the proper function of the brain.
People prefer the sweet foods and a mixed diet.
The brain requires at least 130gm of glucose a day.
Insulin, is the master hormone, that keeps blood serum glucose constant.
Everyone should eat a balanced diet (including sugar).
The body uses calories efficiently, when one's weight is stable, then calories in = calories out.
Exercise is necessary to best achieve calorie balance.
Given enough protein, vitamins and minerals in the diet, calorie intake is a good measure dietary quality.
A high-fat diet is 45% to 55% fat.
A low carbohydrate diet (Often called a high-protein diet) and is less than 300gm of carbohydrate a day.
High fat diets increase insulin resistance.
Glucose monitoring and insulin injection should be the standard treatment for type 2 diabetes
The LCHF diet is a fringe diet fad, that is possibly dangerous.
Diets like the Banting diet are difficult to sustain.

Sensible Modification of the Daily Practice

The window of opportunity is at breakfast time. You wake up burning fat. If you can eat a satisfying full breakfast, without any carbohydrate or sugar, there will be no hunger, and insulin will not turn "on" and fat burning will continue.

Change One: Eat bacon and eggs with kale or silver beet, or lamb chops with tomato and egg, or sausages and mushrooms and egg. Eat liver, or Ox heart, or chicken livers, or sweet-breads. (Offal meats are very high in essential vitamins and minerals.) Have tea or coffee without sweetening. Eat well, and you can skip morning tea.

Change Two: Make your evening meal the last meal of the day. That means that you can drink tea or coffee after 7pm, but you will eat no carbohydrate or fruit before bedtime. This has the effect of increasing the overnight fast by about three hours.

Those changes create a daily fast that's longer than usual, (about 12 hours) and is extended beyond breakfast because of the foods you choose for breakfast. Fat burning is extended every day (To about 15 hours.). Many people will find they lose weight that way.

If that's not enough dietary modification, to keep your weight under control, perhaps you need to abandon the Standard American Diet, as your objective, and look seriously at a LCHF diet.


Left Pointing ArrowReturn to Diet Homepage
Printed from, http://www.openfuture.biz/diet/Mixed-Diet-Paradigm-tab.html